Guide

Lost your mailbox key? Who owns the lock, and who to call

A lost mailbox key sounds like a five-minute problem until you try to work out whose problem it is. It comes down to who owns the lock, and that is usually easy to find out.By Pacific Beach LocksmithUpdated November 8, 20265 min read

Who owns the lock decides who you call

Most mailboxes fall into one of three groups:

  • A box the Postal Service owns and maintains, which includes some neighborhood cluster boxes. Your first call is the post office that delivers your mail.
  • A mailbox bank the building owns, at an apartment complex, condo building or HOA. Call the landlord, property manager or HOA, who can authorize a locksmith to replace your compartment lock.
  • Your own locking mailbox at the curb or on the wall by your door. That one's yours, and replacing the lock is ordinary residential lock work.

Don't go by looks. Cluster boxes bought by a developer or an HOA look a lot like the ones the Postal Service owns.

The two locks on a shared mailbox

A cluster box or an apartment mailbox bank has two kinds of lock. The carrier's lock, often called the arrow lock, opens the master door or the whole front so the carrier can load every compartment at once. It belongs to the Postal Service even when the building owns the box, and Postal Service locks and keys are protected by federal law (18 U.S.C. Section 1704). A locksmith never touches it. Parcel lockers are on the carrier's side too. The carrier loads one and leaves its key in your compartment, and that key stays in the locker once you've used it.

Your compartment lock is the small cam lock on your own door. It belongs to whoever owns the box, and it's the only lock that matters when your key goes missing.

How to find out which kind you have

  1. Renting? Ask your landlord or property manager. In an apartment building the mailbox bank usually belongs to the building, and either way the manager will know.
  2. Condo or HOA community? Ask the HOA or its management company. Many own their mailbox banks and handle compartment locks through a locksmith.
  3. House on a neighborhood cluster box with no HOA? Ask your post office whether the box is theirs.
  4. A locking box you or a previous owner put up? It's yours.

Still not sure? The post office that delivers your mail knows whether a box is theirs. If it isn't, the lock is the building's, the HOA's or yours to replace.

If the Postal Service owns the box

Call or visit your post office. On a box the Postal Service owns and maintains, the post office replaces the compartment lock and issues the new keys. It keeps no spare keys, and when every key is lost the new lock is at the customer's expense. The Postal Service says there's no set fee and the charge depends on local costs. Ask what they need from you and how long it takes, and bring photo ID and something showing your address.

A locksmith can't do this one, us included. If anyone offers to change the lock on a Postal Service box, say no and go to the post office instead.

If the building, the HOA or you own the box

On a privately owned box, the compartment lock is the owner's to replace. In a rental the landlord or manager approves the work, and who pays usually comes down to the lease, as it does with any key (see our guide to California rental lock rules). In an HOA, the board or the management company signs off.

It's a short job. With no key, the old lock is picked or drilled out, since it's being replaced anyway. A new cam lock that fits the box goes into the same door, and you get new keys. Mailbox locks vary by manufacturer in size, cam length and turn direction, so text us a photo of the lock and the brand name on the box. The details, including several compartments in one visit, are on our mailbox lock replacement page.

Have these ready:

  • Photo ID and proof that you live at the address, such as a lease or a utility bill.
  • The owner's or manager's approval: a text or email we can see, or a number we can call.
  • The address and your box or unit number.

For your own curbside or wall box, ID and proof of address are enough. Managers and boards can see how we work with property managers and HOAs.

Your mail in the meantime

Mail keeps going into your compartment while you sort out the key, and a locked box is a safe place for it to wait. The bigger worry is a box that was pried open or no longer closes. Tell the post office if that's happened, because delivery to a box that won't lock can be suspended until it's repaired, and you'd pick up your mail at the post office in the meantime. Report suspected mail theft to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.

Don't pry the door yourself. You'll bend a door that only needed a new lock and end up with a box that won't shut.

If you're settling into a new place, ask for the compartment lock to be changed, since anyone with the last tenant's key can still open it. Near the beach, small mailbox locks are among the first to seize in salt air. If your key has started to stick, see the guide to a key that won't turn.

Questions people ask

Can a locksmith open my mailbox?

Yes, if the box is your own, or if it's privately owned and you have the owner's or manager's approval. A locksmith can't change the lock on a box the Postal Service owns, and never touches the carrier's master lock on any box. If you're not sure which you have, ask your post office.

Who pays for a new mailbox lock in an apartment?

It depends on the lease and on why the lock is being changed. A lost key is often the tenant's cost, while a worn-out lock or a change the manager wants between tenants is usually the building's. Ask the manager before booking anything, since they have to approve the work either way.

My key broke off in the mailbox lock. Now what?

Leave it alone and call whoever owns the lock. Digging at it usually pushes the piece deeper. On a Postal Service box, go to the post office. On a private box, a locksmith can extract the piece or replace the lock with the owner's approval. More in the broken key guide.

Should I change the mailbox lock when I move in?

Yes, if you can get the owner's approval. Previous tenants, and anyone they gave a copy to, may still have a key to your compartment. In a building, ask the manager to change it at move-in. On a Postal Service box, the post office is supposed to change the lock between residents, so ask whether that was done.

Rather talk it through?

Call or text and describe what's going on. If it needs a visit, you'll hear the price before we head out.

Call (858) 842-9337(858) 842-9337 Text us

Have your ID handy, plus something showing it's your home or car.