Guide

Key broke off in the lock? What to do next

A snapped key feels like a disaster, but getting the piece out is usually quick, routine work if nobody has glued or forced anything first. Most of the useful advice is about what not to do while you wait.By Pacific Beach LocksmithUpdated November 8, 20265 min read

Why keys snap in the first place

Keys rarely break for no reason. A brass key flexes a little every time it turns, and after years of that the metal fatigues at the narrow neck where the blade meets the head. One morning the lock takes more effort than usual, you twist harder, and the blade stays in the door. The usual causes:

  • A worn key. An old key, or a copy of a copy, has thin shoulders and rounded cuts, and needs more force to turn the same lock.
  • A stiff or corroded lock. Near the beach, salt air corrodes the cylinder and sand works into the keyway, so the key takes the strain. The salt air hardware guide explains why.
  • A deadbolt that binds. If you have to push, pull or lift the door to get the bolt across, the key is being used as a lever, and it was never made for that.

What's safe to try, and when to stop

First, stop turning. Every extra twist on the stub can push the fragment deeper or bend the pins it rests on.

If a piece is sticking out far enough to grip, try needle-nose pliers or sturdy tweezers and a slow, straight pull with no twisting, plus a slight up-and-down wiggle. If it hasn't moved after a few careful tries, leave it.

If the break is flush with the face of the lock or below it, there's nothing to grip, and this is where most of the damage gets done. Leave it for a locksmith.

It also matters where the lock was when the key broke. A pin-tumbler key only comes out when the cylinder is back in the position where the key went in. If it snapped mid-turn, the fragment is trapped until someone turns the cylinder back with a proper tool.

If the broken key was your only way in, you also have a house lockout, and both get handled in one visit.

Keep the head of the key, and the tip once it's out. Held together, the two halves are often enough to cut a new key.

What makes it worse

  • Superglue on a toothpick, the trick you'll find all over the internet. The glue runs into the pins and springs and sets in seconds, and a simple extraction becomes a new lock.
  • Pushing the other half, or a spare key, into the keyway. It drives the fragment deeper.
  • Turning the cylinder with a screwdriver or the stub. It can shear pins and bend the parts behind the cylinder, and on a car it's a common way to ruin an ignition.
  • Oil or WD-40. Both leave a film that holds dust and grit in the pins. If anything goes in the keyway, make it a short burst of dry PTFE lubricant.
  • Drilling. It destroys the lock, and it's never the first step for a broken key.

How a locksmith gets it out

The usual tools are thin steel blades with a small hook or barb, slim enough to slide into the keyway beside the fragment, catch one of its cuts and draw it straight out. If the key snapped mid-turn, the cylinder is turned back to its starting position first so the pins release it.

A fragment jammed deep in a corroded cylinder may mean taking the cylinder out of the door and opening it up, the same way it's opened for a rekey. You hear the price before anyone is dispatched, with no service call fee, and the pricing questions explain how quotes work.

Will the lock survive, and where does the new key come from?

Usually the lock is fine. If nothing was glued or forced, it works normally once the fragment is out. The exceptions are a glued lock and one that was already worn or pitted, which is often why the key broke in the first place. For those, repairing or replacing the lock is the better fix, and the rekey or replace guide walks through the choice.

When the only key is in two pieces

You don't need a working key to get a new one. A locksmith can cut one from the two halves, or decode the pins with the cylinder open. A key cut to the correct depths often works better than the one that broke, since it doesn't copy years of wear. And while the cylinder is out, it can be rekeyed to a new key so any old copies stop working.

If the key broke in the car

Car door locks get the same treatment as a house lock. The ignition needs more care. Leave the car in park with the parking brake on, and don't turn the ignition with the stub, pliers or a screwdriver. Ignition wafers bend easily, and a forced ignition can leave the steering lock jammed.

If a piece sticks out, the same gentle, straight pull applies. Otherwise a locksmith can extract it at the car and check the ignition, with ignition repair on site if it's damaged. Most modern car keys have a transponder chip in the head, so the new key has to be programmed to the car before it will start the engine. That's part of car key replacement, done where the car is parked. Have the year, make and model ready when you call.

Stop it happening again

  • Retire keys that are bent, cracked at the neck or worn smooth, and cut new ones from a good original rather than the worn copy.
  • Keep a spare somewhere other than your key ring.
  • Fix a stiff lock. Clean it and use a dry PTFE lubricant, never oil.
  • If you have to push or lift the door to turn the key, get the door and strike adjusted. The guide to a key that sticks or won't turn covers each symptom.

Questions people ask

Can I use superglue to pull out a broken key?

No. Glue runs off the fragment into the pins and springs and sets there, and a glued cylinder usually has to be replaced. If a piece is sticking out, a straight pull with needle-nose pliers is as far as you should go. If not, leave it for a locksmith.

How long does broken key extraction take?

Most extractions take a few minutes once the locksmith is at the door. A fragment jammed deep in a corroded cylinder, or a lock stuck mid-turn, can mean pulling the cylinder and opening it up, which takes longer.

Can you make a new key from a broken one?

Usually, yes. The two halves held together are often enough to cut a new key, and if they aren't, the cuts can be read from the lock itself. For a car, the new key is cut and its chip programmed at the vehicle.

Rather talk it through?

Call or text and describe what's going on. If it needs a visit, you'll hear the price before we head out.

Call (858) 842-9337(858) 842-9337 Text us

Have your ID handy, plus something showing it's your home or car.