Guide

Rekey or replace your locks? How to decide

Rekeying and replacing solve different problems. Pick the wrong one and you either pay for hardware you didn't need or end up with new keys to the same weak door.By Pacific Beach LocksmithUpdated November 8, 20266 min read

What rekeying actually does

A pin-tumbler lock has a row of small spring-loaded pins in different lengths, set to match the cuts on one key. Rekeying means taking the cylinder out, swapping those pins for a set that matches a newly cut key, and putting it back together. The lock looks and works exactly as it did, and every old key is now useless.

A standard lock takes a locksmith about ten to fifteen minutes, and locks that share a keyway can be set to one key at the same visit, so the front door, back door, side gate and garage all open with the same key.

Rekeying doesn't make a weak lock strong, though. The cylinder, bolt, strike plate and screws are the ones you had before, so if the hardware was the problem, it still is.

When rekeying is the right call

Rekey when the lock works well and the only problem is who has a key.

  • You just moved in. Previous owners or tenants, cleaners, contractors, and nobody knows how many copies. Sellers and landlords don't always rekey before handing over the keys, so unless you know it was done, assume it wasn't.
  • A key is lost, stolen or never came back. Especially if it was on a ring with anything that shows your address. If the loss also has you standing outside, the lockout guide covers the next twenty minutes.
  • Someone moved out. A roommate, a partner, an employee, a tenant. Rekeying costs less than new locks and saves you chasing the keys back.
  • You own or manage rentals. Rekeying between tenants is a routine part of residential lock work.
  • You want one key for every door. Keying alike is done by rekeying, as long as the locks share a keyway.

When replacing wins

Replace when the hardware itself is the weak point, or when you want something the old lock can't do.

  • It's worn, sticky or corroded. A sticky key is sometimes only a worn key or a dry cylinder, the cheap causes in our guide to a key that won't turn. Close to the ocean, though, salt air pits plated finishes and can seize a lock's moving parts, and rekeying a corroded cylinder is money spent on a lock that's about to fail anyway. Our coastal hardware guide covers what to buy instead.
  • It's builder-grade. Light knob locks and thin deadbolts that came with the house. New pins won't make them any sturdier.
  • There's no deadbolt. A knob lock on its own holds the door shut with a short spring latch. Adding a deadbolt is an installation, including boring the door if it needs it.
  • You want a smart lock or keypad. You can't rekey your way to a keypad; fitting a keypad or smart lock means new hardware.
  • The keyways don't match. If the locks have three different keyways and you want one key for all of them, some need new cylinders or new locks.
  • It's broken. A spinning cylinder, a bolt that won't throw, a snapped tailpiece. Sometimes it can be repaired, and sometimes the repair isn't worth it.
  • Someone forced the door. A bent or pried deadbolt gets replaced, and repair after a break-in often adds a reinforced strike, plus a rekey if keys went missing.

Keying alike, master keys and SmartKey

Keyed alike

Locks with the same keyway, the shape of the slot the key slides into, can be pinned to one key. Keyways mostly follow the brand, and a standard Kwikset key won't go into a Schlage lock, which is why a whole-house rekey sometimes means swapping one odd lock so the rest can match.

Master keys

For a duplex, a small building or a business, a master key system gives each door its own key and lets one key open them all. It's a rekey with more planning, and a common setup for landlords and commercial properties.

Kwikset SmartKey

With a working key and the SmartKey tool, a SmartKey cylinder can be rekeyed in seconds without taking anything apart. Lose the only working key and that shortcut is gone: the cylinder has to come out and be reset in a special cradle, which is usually a locksmith's job.

Lock grades, in one paragraph

Many locks are certified to an ANSI/BHMA grade, from 3 (basic) to 1 (heaviest duty). The grade comes from cycle, strength and impact testing, meaning how many uses the lock survives and how much force it takes. It doesn't measure how hard the lock is to pick, which is rated separately, so a Grade 1 deadbolt isn't automatically pick-resistant. For a front door near the beach, a sensible target is a Grade 1 or 2 deadbolt in a corrosion-resistant finish, with a reinforced strike plate and long screws into the framing.

The cheapest security upgrade on most doors is a set of longer strike plate screws. The short ones that come with most locks only bite into the door jamb, while three-inch screws go through it into the framing behind. A locksmith can swap them during a rekey or an install.

A decision checklist

Go down the list. The first "yes" is usually your answer.

  • Lock is broken, spinning, seized or visibly corroded: replace.
  • You want a deadbolt where there isn't one, or a keypad or smart lock: replace (install).
  • Lock works fine and you just need the old keys dead: rekey.
  • You want one key for several locks with the same keyway: rekey (keyed alike).
  • Locks take different keyways and you want one key: replace the odd ones, rekey the rest.
  • Not sure what you have: text us a photo of the lock.

Prices vary by job, but a rekey is mostly labor plus a few pins and new keys, while a replacement is hardware plus labor. Rekeying a lock that's about to fail is the one choice that costs you twice. The pricing questions explain how quotes work.

Questions people ask

Can every lock be rekeyed?

Most standard pin-tumbler locks can, including most deadbolts, knob locks, lever locks and mortise cylinders. Some very cheap locks aren't built to come apart or aren't worth the labor, badly corroded cylinders may not survive disassembly, and some high-security locks need parts ordered or can only be rekeyed through an authorized dealer. A locksmith can usually tell which kind yours is by looking at it.

Does rekeying make my lock more secure?

Not by itself. Rekeying controls who has a key, but the lock body, the bolt and the strike stay the same. If security is the goal, pair the rekey with a reinforced strike plate and long screws, or move up to a higher-grade deadbolt. If the worry is one particular person with a key, a rekey takes care of it.

I rent in Pacific Beach. Should I rekey?

Ask your landlord or property manager first. Many leases require permission for lock changes and a copy of any new key, and our guide to California rental lock law covers who pays. Plenty of managers rekey between tenants as a matter of course, and if yours didn't, many will agree to it.

Rather talk it through?

Call or text and describe what's going on. If it needs a visit, you'll hear the price before we head out.

Call (858) 842-9337(858) 842-9337 Text us

Have your ID handy, plus something showing it's your home or car.